Christy by Carole Bolton (1960)
Christy soon became caught between her teen-age world and an impossible dream. She found herself saying catty things about Julie, the thirty-year-old librarian who had always been dear to her--until Gideon's arrival. She quarreled with Frank, a wonderfully solemn student of archaeology, whom she denounced as a callow youth. And she learned, finally, that even when love goes away, its sad, sweet poignancy remains.
Christy's efforts to win Gideon are sometimes childish and absurd, sometimes agelessly feminine. In this delightful book, which introduces a fresh new writing talent, Carole Bolton describes them with a keen awareness of the rue and humor and touching reality of love at sixteen. (from the inside flap)